Maximize the Value of Your Accounting Practice: Why Selling to a Doorknock is Not Recommended

Business Brokering Monday 20th of February 2023

Today’s hypothetical for accounting practice owners: Imagine you are seeking to sell your house. Somebody knocks on your door and makes you an offer. It seems legitimate, the buyer has the funds, the terms pass your first inspection. Do you sign on the dotted line?

On the face of it this seems like a pretty silly question. Obviously you’d have some questions for your buyer, first among them being “are you prepared to offer me market price?”

“You bet! The price I’m offering you is market price!

And at that point they’d actually be correct, because if they’re a market of one then whatever price they offer is the market price by definition.

And that’s why you’d shut the door in their face, right?

Well, not always. A surprising number of practice owners looking to sell their business are willing to see things from the “bird in the hand beats two in the bush” perspective.

But it’s a false perspective. You don’t need to accept that the market only has one offer available. To do so is to guarantee that you are not seeing the true market price for your asset. 

So while it may seem more convenient to sell your practice to the single door-knocker this convenience can come at a severe cost. You will most likely be sacrificing price and terms on the sale of your business, and that assumes that the door-knocker's transaction is successfully completed.

The better option is to have your practice sold via a professionally managed competitive tender process with a broader buyer marketplace. Here are some reasons why:

  1. Increased Competition: A competitive tender process attracts multiple buyers, which can increase the level of competition among them and drive up the price. With multiple buyers bidding for the business, there is a greater chance of getting a higher offer.
  2. Better Negotiating Position: With multiple offers on the table, you are in a stronger negotiating position to get the best terms and conditions for the sale of your business. You can compare the offers and choose the one that is the most favourable for you.
  3. Better Deal Terms: By attracting multiple buyers, a competitive tender process can also provide the seller with more leverage in negotiating better deal terms. For example, the seller may be able to negotiate more favourable terms on retention, remuneration during transition, office leasing and other important aspects of the transaction.
  4. Confidentiality: A competitive tender process can also help to maintain confidentiality and protect the seller's reputation, as the process is usually conducted by an intermediary in a confidential manner and the identity of the seller is kept private.
  5. Independent Valuation: A competitive tender process usually involves several bids for your business. It can effectively provide an independent valuation of the business, which provides the seller with a better understanding of the market value of their business and can help to ensure that you receive a fair price.
  6. Professional Advice: A competitive tender process is usually managed by a professional advisor such as a business broker, who has the knowledge and expertise to guide the seller through the process and negotiate the best possible deal whilst saving you a significant amount of time and risk.

Overall, a competitive tender process provides a more structured and successful method of selling a business. When compared to dealing with a single opportunistic buyer the result is better on price, better on terms and more likely to succeed.

Your practice is your legacy. Don’t leave it in the hands of the first smiling salesman to arrive on your doorstep.

Mark Witt CA

Mark is the Head of Brokering at Business Exchange with over 20 years experience and 400+ completed transactions


Read more articles

The Role of Equity Participation in Retaining Talent and Productivity

Equity participation - whether through full partnership or employee share schemes - emerges as a crucial strategy for "locking in" key team members and adding deeper meaning to their professional endeavours.

Read More
The Strategic Advantage of Off-Market Mergers for Small Practices

For small practices, off-market opportunities – strategic mergers with larger firms - offer a pathway not just to expansion but to a redefinition of what small practices can achieve when they leverage the right partnerships.

Read More
Pragmatic Strategies for Successful Client Transition in Accounting and Planning Practices

These strategies aim to preserve the relationships you've meticulously built and seek to enhance the practice's growth and continuity post-transition. The focus: keep the client's best interest at heart.

Read More
Exploring Flexible Succession Strategies in the Accounting and Planning Marketplaces

In today's dynamic accounting marketplace, vendors contemplating retirement or looking to scale down their involvement face a landscape rich with opportunities.

Read More
The Business Exchange Network - Transforming Business Brokering

The sun is fast setting on the old way of business brokering. The privileged position of a business broker as a gatekeeper to information and connection is under threat in a world where clients can now find each other via searches on smartphones, LinkedIn etc., and that means the most fundamental adage of business survival applies: adapt, or die.

Read More
About Business Exchange's Private Broker Network™ (PBN)

The Private Broker Network™ (PBN) is a members-only walled garden marketplace for business brokering and succession transactions. It is intended to be used by large networks of member businesses such as financial planning dealer groups and franchises.

Read More
The Importance of Allocating Time for Navigating Client Relationships Post-Sale

Client relationships within an accounting practice portfolio are anchored on mutual respect, trust and understanding. They can take a professional lifetime to build. As you near retirement, the onus is on you to ensure a smooth transfer of these relationships to guarantee continued success for the practice.

Read More
Timing is Everything: Guarding Your Practice's Value at Retirement

Retirement, while a celebratory milestone, presents unique challenges for accountants. Successful transition demands a precise strategy to secure the value built up over a lifetime of professional practice.

Read More
Partnerships in the New Era: Navigating the Future with Toffler's Timeless Insights

Beneath the warm glow of a Zoom call, two business partners lock eyes, or rather cursors, and prepare for a brave new world. Their partnership, formed during the great pandemic, has been forged in the crucible of COVID-19. Now, as they brace for an AI-enabled future, they turn to the prophetic wisdom of futurist Alvin Toffler for guidance.

Read More
Expanding Horizons: How Joining an Accounting Partnership Can Transform Your Sole Practice

As an accountant, you've likely experienced the challenges of managing a sole practice, from juggling multiple clients to staying on top of industry trends. Merging with an established accounting partnership can allow you to streamline your operations, expand your client base and boost your professional growth.

Read More
Cultural Fit - What Is It and Why Is It Important in a Successful Accounting Practice Sale or Merger

I have observed that one of the most critical factors for a successful accounting practice sale or merger is cultural fit. This elusive yet essential concept can be the difference between a thriving, synergistic partnership and a disappointing, unproductive alliance.

Read More
Capital Partners Versus Banks: A New Paradigm for Financing Expansion in Accounting & Fin Planning

Capital partners are emerging as a potent alternative to banks for financing expansion via acquisition, especially within accounting and financial planning practices.

Read More
Increasing Dealer Group Charges Drive Financial Planning Book Sales

In the first quarter of 2020 we've seen a material increase in enquiry from vendors of small financial planning books seeking to sell. And it's not just Covid-19 or FASEA driving this trend.

Read More
Merging to Retire - Is this an Option for You?

Succession can take many forms depending on your situation and goals. Considering a merger can give you options beyond a simple all-or-nothing sale.

Read More
Greater Expectations - How to Not Sabotage Your Sale

Selling your business is a high-complexity high-stakes process. Some transactions take months to complete. Some never complete at all.

Read More
Selling Your Accounting Practice - Items affecting Price

Ever since we commenced selling accounting practices in 2001 the normal range of price for accounting fee parcels hasn't varied much from where it sits today which is 70 cent to $1.10 of expected recurring turnover.

Read More
Quest for the Perennial Long Weekend

A long weekend is a welcome break from the weekly routine, a chance to rejuvenate and reconnect with family. Maybe a short trip away from home, fishing trip, weekender or just a chance to put your feet up and forget the schedule for a day. What if this were the norm, not the exception?

Read More
Appointing an equity partner: is it the right succession move for you?

There are many pathways to succession. Many practitioners in the accounting space are choosing to broaden their succession options by appointing an equity partner. But how do you find the right one?

Read More
Selling Your Financial Planning Business in Uncertain Times - When Is The Best Time to Sell?

With the pending FASEA requirements and predicted changes as a result of the Hayne Royal Commission into the Financial Services industry we are certain to see planners exiting the industry in increasing numbers. Should you go? And if so, when?

Read More
Accounting Succession - Asking the Right Questions

When I bring up the topic of succession with accountants there is a common theme: "I want to improve my work/life balance and maybe take some equity off the table, but I don't want to retire yet."

Read More
Downsizing Your Accounting Practice (And Getting Paid For It)

One of the most disappointing things I see is when an overworked practitioner writes to some of their long-time clients to say that they can't represent them anymore. It's the business goodwill equivalent to burning cash.

Read More